Should
You Correct A Puppy
With A Pinch Collar?
By
Adam G. Katz
Hi, Adam!
My
husband and I recently purchased a white German Shepherd.
She is 12 weeks old today and quite a handful. Sometimes
she can be so sweet, but other times she is actually quite
vicious.
Well,
I don't know if vicious is the right word, but when I tell
her “No!” she just gets more agitated and lunges
at me with her teeth bared.
I
got a small pinch collar since she's a puppy but I have
a question as to how it should fit. When I take 2 prongs
out it is snug against her neck and I worry about it being
too tight. When I only take 1 prong out, it sort of slides
down her neck a little bit and she constantly scratches
at it and it circles around her neck and doesn't stay put.
Which is the right fit?
She
is really a handful and I think the pinch collar is a great
tool, but I want to make sure it fits right so as not to
cause her any discomfort.
You
say in the book that you should be able to slide half a
finger in there, but I guess I am just confused as to how
you should judge the fit.
[To
read about the book she’s referring to, click here:
http://www.dogproblems.com/secretsbook.htm
]
Please
help! I'm afraid my time is running out to get her to start
obeying me. She doesn't see me as the Alpha dog quite yet
and it is very frustrating to be with her for long periods
of time. When I say "Duchess, come" she only comes
when she feels like it. With the pinch collar, what is the
best way to make sure she comes each time I call her? I
don't want to go around yanking on her neck, but at the
same time she needs to respect me. Any tips you can give
me on making sure she sees me as the boss would be very
helpful!
Thanks,
Cassidy
Dear
Cassidy:
When
I refer to “half a finger space” in regard to
the proper fitting of the pinch collar, what I mean is:
-
If the average person’s finger is ½ inch wide,
then there should be aproximately ¼ inch of space
between the end of the prong and the skin of the dog’s
neck.
So,
why don’t I just say, “1/4 inch of space”?
Because it’s easier to judge by sticking your finger
beneath the prong than it is to break out your old high
school ruler.
Many
of you (newsletter subscribers) are no doubt wondering why
I would recommend a pinch collar for a puppy. And my answer
is: I’m not. At least not for most puppies.
But
there are some puppies who will not respond to a simple
diversion or verbal, “No.” They will bite and
cause puncture wounds on your legs and arms if they are
not corrected for this behavior. So, if you've tried the
other methods for dealing with “puppy nipping”
that I’ve outlined in the book, then you’ll
need to progress to a small pinch collar. (Also described
in the book.)
“But
aren’t they too young for a pinch collar?” you’re
probably thinking.
The
answer is: No.
They
ARE too young for formal obedience training. (I.E., Sit,
Down, Come, Heel, Stay). [This should start when you see
the adult teeth come in… at aproximately 4 to 5 months
of age.]
But
a puppy SHOULD be corrected for biting… if you’ve
found that diverting his attention to a chew toy or another
activity is not working.
Why?
Because the mother dog would not allow the puppy to bite
her. If the pup bites her too hard, she will turn and bite
the puppies neck.
From
the puppies perspective, THIS HURTS.
But
it does not cause damage.
And
that’s why the puppy chooses not to bite the mama
dog any more. Because it doesn’t feel good.
This
is the same reason that it’s okay to correct a puppy
for excessively hard biting with the pinch collar. The pinch
collar replicates the mama dog.
Trust
me on this: I’ve seen 11 week-old Rottweiler puppies
and 10 week-old Jack Russell Terrier puppies who had biten
through (literally) their owners fingers with their needle-like
teeth. The owners are almost in tears with the idea that
they may have to put their puppy to sleep.
They’ve
tried all the nonsense garbage your read in the dog magazines.
Stuff
like shrieking in a high-pitched voice. Or putting the puppy
in the crate. Or turning your back on the dog. But none
of it works on a puppy who is intent on biting down as hard
as he can on your soft, human flesh.
Getting
back on course… When you correct the puppy, just use
common sense. Simply because your car can accelerate up
to 140 mph. does not mean that you should or need to drive
that fast. The same goes for the pinch collar. If you’re
an adult and you can employ reason and common sense, then
you should be able to tailor the intensity of your correction
to appropriately match your dog’s temperament.
How
do you do this? You test.
If
you correct the puppy for biting, then next you should immediately
offer him your hand again. If he immediately bites you again…
then you now know that your correction wasn’t meaningful.
For
more dog training
information, visit the following links:
Main
site: Dog Training
Secrets of a Professional Dog Trainer Book--
http://www.dogproblems.com/secretsbook.htm
Dog Training Articles: http://www.dogproblems.com/articles.htm
Dog Training products: http://www.dogproblems.com/products.htm
Dog Training Discussion Forum: http://www.dogproblems.com/dogtalk/
You
are welcome to use this article written by Adam G. Katz
for your web site or publication.
Our only requirement is that you must maintain the copyright,
byline, and link back to this site. Copyright 2002 By Dogproblems.com
All Rights Reserved.
Subscribe
to our free weekly dog training tips e-zine! http://www.dogproblems.com

| DogsCorner
Home |
Dog
training, grooming, health care, dog supplies, dog
beds, collars, crates, doors, food, gates, houses,
tags, toys & treats
|
| Dog
Beds |
Benefits
of dog beds and types of dog beds
|
| Dog
Collars
|
Dog
collars, dog training collars, electronic dog collars
and bark control collars to train my dog.
|
| Dog
Crates |
Benefits, tips for buying dog crates
and crate training
|
| Dog
Doors
|
The types of dog doors, from standard
and patio dog doors to electronic and automatic dog
doors |
| Dog
Food
|
About
dog food and types of dog food |
| Dog
Gates |
About
dog gates
|
| Dog
Grooming |
Dog
grooming tips and dog grooming supplies for your dog.
|
| Dog
Health Care |
Total
dog health care from flea and tick control to dog
vitamins, supplements and dog medical health care
insurance
|
| Dog
Houses |
About
dog houses and dog house plans to build different
dog houses designs
|
| Dog
Supplies |
Dog
supplies, from dog
beds, collars, doors, food, houses, treats, toys,
dog training, grooming and health care supplies
|
| Dog
Tags |
Dog
tags & dog id tags for dog identification
|
| Dog
Toys |
Types
of dog toys and tips for buying and using dog toys.
|
| Dog
Training |
Dog
training, dog training collars and dog training supplies
for easier and more effective dog obedience training.
|
| Dog
Treats |
Dog
treats for dog training |